A few weeks before the 1997 general election I was working for a Training and Enterprise Council, a long-forgotten quango that brought together youth and adult training and economic development. I’d written a paper for the board about NEETs, young people not in education, employment or training. It opened with a striking figure. There were 1,200 young people in County Durham who were NEET. The figure was true, but only at the actual moment I wrote it.
It found its way into a press release, which in turn was picked up by Newsnight. Would I like to come on the show and tell them how I’d arrived at this exact number? Apparently people all around the country had been wrestling with the tricky issue of how to count exactly how many NEETs there were. I’d inadvertently become an expert. Then two days later a general election was called and they lost all interest.
Nearly thirty years after Newsnight lost interest, Alan Milburn published his plans for tackling the same problem. The review was all over the news for days. The BBC even gave it the sort of front page coverage even if the Government was rather less forthcoming about which bits it intends to implement.
What is Milburn proposing?
Between April and June this year, the Office for National Statistics estimated that 981,000 people aged 16 to 24 in the UK were out of education, employment or training. That’s 13 per cent. Milburn wants to get the rate down to about 5 per cent by 2036. The report’s own modelling puts it at 6.8 per cent if the package is implemented in full, so even on its own assumptions there’s some distance between what the reforms are expected to achieve and what Milburn hopes to achieve.
Milburn proposes a legal right to a route into education, training or work, and a second guarantee of the help you need to take it up. In England, a locally led Youth Opportunity Service would bring together careers advice, training, employment support and help with health problems. If you needed sustained help, you’d have a named adviser who knew your circumstances and was responsible for what happened next. An 18 to 24-year-old who needed that help could get it whether or not they claimed benefits.
The offer could be a college place, an apprenticeship, a work placement or a subsidised job. If you’ve taken part and you’re still out of work and education, Milburn says the state should fund a six-month paid job with an employer, where paid work is realistic with support. There’s only so much a careers adviser can do if there’s nowhere to send you.
The more contentious part is welfare. Milburn wants young people who can work to be expected to take up opportunities and engage with support, and he wants long-term financial security for people with profound and lasting disabilities. He also says the support and opportunities should be in place before the changes to benefits take effect. Ministers have backed the guarantee and committed to a locally led service. They’re still considering the wider welfare proposals, with a White Paper due early next year.
What we tried in County Durham
The project I worked on had three strands. We wanted to open up vocational education and training to young people who hadn’t thrived in a traditional academic setting, give them intensive careers support and offer them Outward Bound-style activities.
Good vocational training leading to a job was the obvious starting point. Careers advice and guidance was trickier. My own very short discussions with careers staff suggested either the police or the Bank of England. At Belmont Comp, the careers advisers seemed to recommend exclusively jobs that came with a free uniform.
The Outward Bound activities were a harder sell. Some of the young people we were working with had a history of trouble with the authorities, and some people felt that taking them hiking or kayaking was a reward for bad behaviour. There will always be people whose solution to every problem is to be meaner and more miserable.
What interested me was what happened when you took young people out of their usual surroundings and asked them to do something they’d never done before. A few days away could give them a chance to make decisions, do something difficult with other people and find out they were better at it than they’d expected. We were trying to broaden people’s horizons. That mattered if the choices they could see for themselves were already very narrow.
Who can make it work?
The bit of Milburn’s report with the biggest implications is the attempt to move decisions closer to the people who have to make them work. The benefits system is highly centralised. It can decide whether you meet a set of criteria and what you’re entitled to. Getting someone into a job and helping them stay there can mean finding a course they can get to, getting support for a health problem and persuading an employer to give them a chance. Any one of those things can hold up the others. This is the most fundamental shift in how the welfare state operates since the 1940s.
Milburn wants regional mayors and councils to bring those services together. Intuitively, it makes a lot of sense. It also relies on systems we haven’t yet built everywhere, at a level of government that has very different powers and capacity depending on where you live. A mayor can get the college, the NHS and local employers into the same room. The harder questions are who can commit the money, who can make a decision when those organisations disagree, and who sorts it out when the young person is still waiting three months later.
There’s a much bigger argument about the welfare state here. Milburn’s remit was 16 to 24-year-olds, but the same question applies to plenty of adults. How much should the state spend on supporting people’s incomes, and how much should it spend on the practical help that might let them earn more of their own? A government looking for savings will naturally be attracted by the prospect of a lower benefits bill. The danger is that the Treasury can change the benefit rules much faster than a mayor can build the services that are supposed to make those changes work.
But the fundamental principle is: from each according to their ability to each according to their need. This is a very different way of thinking about the welfare state. The welfare state of the 1940s was born out of communities which were tight knit but homogenous. A less cohesive, more diverse, more isolated society needs to re-think how the welfare state works, otherwise those who oppose it will find it too easy to pull it apart. Alan Milburn
Nearly thirty years ago Newsnight wanted to know how I’d counted 1,200 young people in County Durham. It was a fair question. I’d have been more interested in what happened to those young people six months later. Had they found a course worth doing, or a job they could keep? And if they were still where they’d started, did anyone know why? That’s the test I’d apply to Milburn’s reforms.